The Data Between Winning and Losing Traders

I’m not sure I have shared this with you before, but I used to own a prop firm and I’m here to give you some insights that will help you. (With a free tool at the end)

First, we’ll go over data on the difference between winning and losing traders.

The Data

There’s a clear difference between winning and losing traders. Here’s some of the data that we collected:

Passed = Winning traders

Breached = Losing traders

Trades per day:

  • Passed: 2.5 – 3.15
  • Breached: 7.8 – 8.61

Risk-Reward ratio:

  • Passed: 2.45 – 2.54
  • Breached: 0.56 – 0.97

How long the account lasts:

  • Passed: 9.4 days
  • Breached: 5 – 7.17 days

Win rate:

  • 60–80% of passed traders maintain a win rate of at least 50%
  • Breached: generally low

Generally low here means below 50%.

Stop Loss / Take Profit:

  • Passed: used by most
  • Breached: ignored by many

Lot size management:

  • Passed: adjusted dynamically
  • Breached: many use constant lot sizes

This means that winning traders tend to use a certain % risk of the account for every trade, for losing traders it was just the same size risk without paying attention to how much % risk that is of the account.

Trading strategy:

  • Passed: swing, intraday, controlled scalping
  • Breached: mostly scalping with no discipline

My Thoughts

The losing traders in the data make every beginner mistake in the book, it’s a recipe for disaster. more trades, more losses, no SL, scalping, high risk, it’s not going to end well.

Less is more, don’t trade too much at the start and just focus on great risk management. After that you’ll slowly get better and better.

With PipBack we’ve built a free tool you can use to calculate how long it will take you to pass an evaluation and how much it will then cost you:

 Always here if you need me! 

Arjo Janssens – MMT